Trapshooters Forum banner

Is a $20k gun really THAT much better than a $3k gun?

24K views 172 replies 103 participants last post by  Savage99Stan  
#1 ·
We all like to have nice things in life, and I have my fair share of firearms but my whole arsenal cost less than most of the high end O/Us.

So what exactly are you paying for with a Koler, Perazzi, or Krieghoff? I certainly love to window shop but I'd be scared to death to take it out of the case if I spent that much on a shotgun.

Thanks
 
#2 ·
Is a $100,000 gun better than a $20,000 gun?! $3,000 will get you good craftsmanship, albeit a plain Jane, but the scroll work won't increase your break percentage.

My 90T, built by Kolar, is my high dollar gun... I've owned for 17 years no malfunctions... the gun is now 27 years old...

Affordability is relative to your station in life
 
#6 ·
SImple,

Do you want to drive a Ford Fiesta or a Ford GT? A Chevy Vega or a Cadillac? ETC, ETC. All will get you where you are going. It all depends on what floats your boat! 😆
 
#10 ·
We all like to have nice things in life, and I have my fair share of firearms but my whole arsenal cost less than most of the high end O/Us.

So what exactly are you paying for with a Koler, Perazzi, or Krieghoff? I certainly love to window shop but I'd be scared to death to take it out of the case if I spent that much on a shotgun.

Thanks
It is to me. Can’t answer or speak for anyone else.
 
#16 ·
Only negative thing about a 20,000 dollar gun is it being sold for 500 dollars by your survivors after you die
$500.00? No way!

Mrs. Barker and I already have a deal in place for $350.00 for your guns.

She wanted $1500.00 for your high heel shoe collection but I passed. Haversham, however, has an interest.
 
#17 · (Edited)
Yes,a $15-20000 gun is better built, more hand fitting, etc than a $3000 gun.
Will it break more targets for you (if the stocks fit)- NO!!!
A lot of us shoot very expensive guns because we appreciate the artistry of hand engraving and beautiful wood.
Some of us worked our asses off for a long time and now that we are retired and aging, we choose to enjoy what we put aside while we still can....
Some get enjoyment looking at big bank/stock statements and some of us like to go out and shoot "D Class" scores with a work of art!!!
Paul in Virginia
 
#19 ·
We all like to have nice things in life, and I have my fair share of firearms but my whole arsenal cost less than most of the high end O/Us.

So what exactly are you paying for with a Koler, Perazzi, or Krieghoff? I certainly love to window shop but I'd be scared to death to take it out of the case if I spent that much on a shotgun.

Thanks
It's OK to shoot what you can afford. No one cares besides you.
 
#21 ·
The answer to your title question is no. A $3,000 gun with the adjustable features you need to get an acceptable gun fit a for a consistent mount and your preferred POI will post the same scores as a $20,000 gun.

Comparisons to car and boats is just nonsense in regards to that. They have inherent performance variables. A gun is like a hammer whether it's a $5.00 hammer or a $35.00 hammer you still have to hit the nail.

Now beauty, quality of materials, durability, prestige/satifaction of ownership, etc. are different discussions and aren't what you asked about in you title but can be answered to the different question you posed in your post.
 
#28 ·
The answer to your title question is no. A $3,000 gun with the adjustable features you need to get an acceptable gun fit a for a consistent mount and your preferred POI will post the same scores as a $20,000 gun.

Comparisons to car and boats is just nonsense in regards to that. They have inherent performance variables. A gun is like a hammer whether it's a $5.00 hammer or a $35.00 hammer you still have to hit the nail.

Now beauty, quality of materials, durability, prestige/satifaction of ownership, etc. are different discussions and aren't what you asked about in you title but can be answered to the different question you posed in your post.
I'd have to agree here. Many of us I'm sure have watched guysnuse an ol 870 and keep right up with the 5k+$ gun users. It all about what fits good and feels right and what works for the shooter
 
#23 ·
@JBrooks ...exactly. You can't compare a machine with thousands of moving parts to a shotgun with about 12 moving parts, none of which are moving thousands of times an hour.

At the risk of upsetting certain elements on here, my Turkish Yildiz (admittedly more than 3k USD, but less than that down here) clocked up 50 000 shots recently. It has got me 2 state championships, an Australian team and not a single FTF or other problem, apart from a poorly applied finish (rectified by me) and a rubbish case (rectified by Negrini).

Old guy down here recently went from a Miroku to a P. His scores have decreased, although as he says "I look better when I miss..."

I still lust after other guns, but mostly old model Browning Broadways or English SxS.....