Ok, I thought I would run this by the board members here for their thoughs. This past week in our winter league shoot. ( 4 clubs about 150 shooters)my club tied for first with another club ( 7 birds down). Weekly we count the 5 best shooters for each club. During the shooting, one of our shooters broke a bird and the scorer called it lost. the shooter told the scorer that he broke it but the scorer said he didn't. Then one guy standing next the the scorer said it was a broken bird. The scorer said I don't care I didn't see it break. He ended marking it lost and gave my buddy a 47. Well my buddy was pissed but what could he do. Our club ended up in a tie because of that one bird. I understand if no one said it was broken, but if the shooter said it was broken and a whitness isn't that enough to overide the scorer? Even if it wasn't another member on the line? the whitness interjected as soon as the scorer called lost. I realize we are not shooting for millions of dollars but what is the right thing here. Myself as a scorer if I called lost and two people said it was broken I would simply change the score.