i'm thinking of having a set of barrels worked on [perazzi mx 14 o/u ] by a well known barrelsmith and i keep hearing that they will lose there re-sale value as everyone wants original or un altered bbls any truth to this what is your opinion thanks steve
I had Tom Wilkinson put his choke tubes in my Silver Seitz but I made him stamp it Wilkinson and I,m keeping the papers . Do I think it is worth more with Wilkinson tubes not really . If you have anyone do barrel work have it done by one of the better barrel guys and get a stamp on the barrel .
Factory, unaltered barrels only for me. I got stung on a older BT99 years ago. I could not figure out why it had such a loose pattern for a full choke. Finally had it measured and it appears someone performed a "jugg choke" ream on the gun (I believe that was the term). The barrel was "opened" about 4-5inches from the end and somehow it distorted the ability to pattern correctly. I tried every shot size, light/heavy loads, it impossible to smoke a target at anything past 21 years. BTW, does anyone know what a jugg choke is designed to accomplish? Sure can't be dense patterns.
As already mentioned above. As long as it is a named smith and you keep your paperwork and have the barrel stamped you will be fine. I would buy barrels that are reworked in a heartbeat as long as the facts are in evidence. Tom Seitz lived just up the road in Salem Oregon and I will guarantee you that Tom would have to have worked several life times to produce all the barrels floating around out there that people say he worked. Get them marked and keep the paperwork and you will be just fine.Jeff
nutty1, I have a slightly different take. Firstly, if your barrels perform well I wouln't touch them. Also, I surely would not give them to a smith and say go to .740. That is a lot to take out of those barrels, especially if they are light to start with.
My last gun was a used Perazzi MX-15 with a 34" barrel and chokes. The original barrel was stamped 1.82kg and came with type 4 chokes. Bore dia was .724. A previous owner sent the barrel to Wilkinson for bore work and porting. Bore came back at .740 with three of the chokes worked. That was the a very even patterning barrel, and the softest shooting I ever had. The only problem was the barrel wall was so thin the POI would change when the barrel heated up. After 12 -15 shots on a fast squad I'd have to adjust aim for smoke. Once it moved it seemed to stay there for the rest of the event.
I've shot several other Wilkenson tuned barrels that started life as 1.86kg fixed choke barrels and they did not exhibit the same problem. Recoil was universally softer than 18.7 bore standard barrels.
So, if there is a problem with your barrels I'd send them to Eyster or Wilkinson or Allor (or Skeets if he is still doing that work) and have them stamp the barrel. Then keep the papers. If you later wanted to sell those fixed choke barrels to me, I would not consider it a negative. In fact, it would be a slight positive, because I'd know there are not going to be any barrel, forcing cone, choke, patterning problems. If they were factory barrels, I'd insist on a trial period so I could go out and shoot them for POI and pattern. Would I pay more for them because you had the work done? Probably not. But it would make me more inclined to consider them in the first place.
I gotta ask,,,MEANING ABSOLUTLY NO DISRESPECT AT ALL. Why is a barrel that has been bacobored by Wilkinson any better than if it had been backbored be anyone else?????? I mean,, it is just the process of removing metal to reach the desired bore,, right?? Does he have some "magic" that he applies???
I am not trying to disagree with him,, just want to know,, "why is Wilkinson the man,, and what makes him that"??? Paul
I don't care who the barrelsmith is that performs the work, the proof is in it giving you what you request. I have shot Eyster's work as well as Wilkinson's, and a few lesser known as well. They that were done correctly,gave me the patterns I expected. Are you buying it for resale or your use? Do as you wish with your barrels, I'm sure you won't regret it. I've even had a BT99 barrel that everyone gave up on because it was reamed off center. I sent it off to Briley who straightened it out and installed a set of his tubes and the shooter couldn't have been happier with the end result. He's been breaking targets with it for over ten years since.
guncase, Wilkinson, Allor, Eyster and Skeets change the taper and profile of the forcing cone and choke to change the distribution of shot in the pattern. Each has their own pet profile. Wilkinson removes metal from the barrel (backbore) because that's the only way he can get the choke profile he wants. Allor works on the forcing cone and choke areas, and in the process scuffs up the bore, so he has to polish it out. Nobody takes any more metal out than necessary.
The reason their work is so highly regarded is they don't ruin barrels and they test their work (not sure about Skeets). Briley does nice machining work, but they don't tune and they don't test. Can they improve an already good barrel? Many think so. Can they make a shooter out of a bad barrel? Absolutely.
I think that you have defined the reason people use a particular barrel guy.
it is that you agree with the WAY the change What they do.
To recut the forcing cone to match the bore is essential,, and I'm sure that all the names do this. The choke HAS to be recut to match the customers wish. I just want to know what they do that I can't????