Trapshooters Forum banner

Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 33 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
160 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Trying to find out if anyone has any firsthand experience with a couple of different models of dog field training collar sets for multiple dogs I am considering. Will be using it for two dogs, an English Springer and a Boykin Spaniel. The two sets I am considering are:

SportDOG FieldTrainer SD-400S

Tri-tronics G3 Sport Basic 2-dog

I am interested both in any experience you have with how well they have held up as well as the ability to control two dogs simultaneously with these particular sets.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,782 Posts
Dad, be very careful in using ecollars on your bird dogs! A lot of good potential birddogs have been ruined by the misuse of Edison at a distance! You have two dogs with probably very different tolerance levels? I know the Springer is a fireplug but nothing at all about the Boykin.

No ecollar takes the place of prior obedience training with voice or whistle commands and thats a must before hooking up any dog in order to punish him for mistakes! Read all you can and learn how to properly use one to re-reinforce your verbal or whistle commands and use it to (remind) the dog he's to obey your commands with a warning first! They are great tools but must be used properly, after basic training your buddies!

Hap
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
14,809 Posts
Aside from what Hap mentioned (which is all true), I've heard of some short term issues with the sport dog collars. I have a Tri-tronics dual system that is 5 years old, and have been very happy with it. Before that, I used a DT Systems dual unit that lasted about 4 years.

Get one with a "vibration mode". You can use that as a warning before punishing them regardless if you can acually see them or not.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,425 Posts
I have a sportdog 1825 which is two dog capable. I have had it for over a year and so far it has survived a lot of wet work up here in Alaska. I don't have two dogs but I use it on both channels because I can set it up differently for different training situations. I like the fact that it has a warning beep and a vibration mode along with 24 different levels of stimulation.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
160 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Hap and others - thanks so much for the quick info. Guess I was not real clear in what I am asking about controlling two dogs.

As Hap mentions, our two dogs are much different and at different levels. The Springer is six years old and a great dog that only needs a little correction. The Boykin is a young bundle of energy who is a fast learner of both good and bad habits. The Boykin is the one that needs it. I figure that since I am getting one I might as well get one that I can use for both.

I really need the ability to handle the two dogs very differently. The ability to set things up differently and control the two dogs back and forth is what I am having a hard time discerning from the literature I have read of the various systems.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
I use a dogtra 2 collar set up. One remote controls both collars
Use the beeper function mainly on my English pointer
These are in my opinion the best most reliable hunting collars for the money
This is their web site. http://www.dogtra.com/
Hope this helps
Good hunting

Gary G Peterson
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
I use a dogtra 2 collar set up. One remote controls both collars
Use the beeper function mainly on my English pointer
These are in my opinion the best most reliable hunting collars for the money
This is their web site. http://www.dogtra.com/
Hope this helps
Good hunting

Gary G Peterson
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
I use a dogtra 2 collar set up. One remote controls both collars
Use the beeper function mainly on my English pointer
These are in my opinion the best most reliable hunting collars for the money
This is their web site. http://www.dogtra.com/
Hope this helps
Good hunting

Gary G Peterson
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
22 Posts
I've also had issues with the sport dog collars. Mine seemed to work very sporadically even when fully charged. I now have DT collars and they've worked well so far but I only have about a year's worth of use in them so I have no idea how long they'll last.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
I am strictly an amateur trainer, I wish to add one thing to Hap's
excellent advice. I was training a Llewellyn pup (very easy training dog),
I did not want to make the e-collar punishment, but a replacement for my
chech cord. First thing I set the collar low and held on inside of my wrist,
when I could just feel (level way before it was unpleasant) I put on my pup.
I would then turn up slightly until he would notice, but well below pain.
I came accross an article by George Hickox, he recommended to start in the
yard with a going away command, such as kennel. When the dog enters his
kennel you stop stimulation. George wants the dog to now he can turn off
by doing the right thing. George also does not want the collar to immediately
come running to the trainer, but just do what is asked. This worked so well
my pup wanted the collar on as he later learned it meant either yard work or
later hunting. I feel George Hickox methods made training very simple.

Good luck with both dogs, Gary Owen
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,782 Posts
Dad, my best buddy has 6 bird dogs of various flavors, all good bird dogs too! I have no idea how many ecollars he's bought and used over the years and he knows dogs and ecollars and how to use them PROPERLY too!! He's sold a ton of them to others and still has a bunch for his dogs! I'll give him a call and have him weigh in on your post in a bit, it's that important for the sake of your dogs!

Hap
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
511 Posts
Before the collar is ever used on a dog , the dog should be "conditioned" to it. I'm not going to get into the whole process , because it takes some time and patience with the dog and you. There are some good videos out there. I'd suggest starting there. A pro. trainer who I have a lot of respect for says that an e-collar is both the best and worst training tool ever devised.

That being said , I have 2 Tri-Tronics Pro 100 G3s with 6 recievers for our dogs (pointers). They have 6 levels of continuous and 18 levels of momentary "STIMULATION" , plus a tone button. I'd suggest these to anyone. If you're serious , spend the money up front. You won't regret it. They hold their value too. I say "stimulation" because if used correctly , and the dog is conditioned , you can barely feel anything. I just want to slap the A-holes that brag about "frying" their dogs and put the collar aroud their necks.
Good Luck , properly trained bird dogs are a pleasure to watch ...............
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
300 Posts
Stick with the G3. I have had three Tri tronics since the 70's a 70 model,LS 500, and LR500, and they all still work. I am currently in a G2 500 with three collars. I train both pointing and labs and big T is the only one to hold up to the labs and keep on ticking,pointers are easy on the collars. You will like the field mateing feature if you ever loose either the transmitter or reciever. If you have not used a collar before, you do not train with it, you train then use the collar to reenforce what you have trained.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
10,399 Posts
Agree with the tri tronics G3 but I wouldnt get the sport I would get the upland and then just add an additional receiver if you are going to work both dogs at one time

The upland allows you to turn a beeper colar on and off from the transmitter

Tri Tronics has made a major leap ahead of the competition with the G3--- if it doesnt have a particular feature- you dont want that feature- example is vibration-

Regards from Iowa

Gene
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
893 Posts
I'm not sure of the exact question, but transmitter can be switched between receivers, but the transmitter settings stay the same. If you want to apply different levels of stimulation, you'll have to manually change them. This applies to the G3. I don't know about the others.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
682 Posts
I use a dogtra 2 collar set up also. I have 2 sets. I use mainly the pager function for my 2 Brittanies. They respond to it instantly. Dan Bonillas uses the same setup with his dogs. The Dogtra product is very reliable. We get replacement batteries for both the collars and transmitters at Batteries Plus here in Fresno.

Vince McNamara
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,276 Posts
OH man this is really making me nervous.....people talkin bout puttin a collar on ol two dogs....
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,531 Posts
Buy the Dogtra 2500 T&B (I believe that is the model number). That has a beeper collar and e-collar all in one unit with no top speaker. I've been using Dogra in the grouse woods for about 6 years now and never had a problem of any kind. All of my friends have switched to them and love them as well. I've used several othr brands including the ones you have mentioned and like Dogtra much better. They make a two dog unit.
 
1 - 20 of 33 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top