
Why not have different location for Grand AmericanMost Recent Posts First
|
| Posted By | Posted Date/Time |
| Stumpi24 | 30-Jul-10 - 08:48 PM ET |
| hunter44 | 30-Jul-10 - 09:03 PM ET |
| thebirdislost | 30-Jul-10 - 09:06 PM ET |
| Neil Winston | 30-Jul-10 - 09:15 PM ET |
| BigM-Perazzi | 30-Jul-10 - 09:19 PM ET |
| FRedmon | 30-Jul-10 - 09:37 PM ET |
| fssberson | 30-Jul-10 - 09:50 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 30-Jul-10 - 09:58 PM ET |
| The Rock | 30-Jul-10 - 10:08 PM ET |
| Barry C. Roach | 30-Jul-10 - 10:10 PM ET |
| BigM-Perazzi | 30-Jul-10 - 10:11 PM ET |
| walnutmaker | 30-Jul-10 - 10:30 PM ET |
| frostyman | 30-Jul-10 - 11:05 PM ET |
| Doug Brown | 30-Jul-10 - 11:08 PM ET |
| Stumpi24 | 30-Jul-10 - 11:41 PM ET |
| ljutic73 | 31-Jul-10 - 12:45 AM ET |
| walnutmaker | 31-Jul-10 - 02:11 AM ET |
| Hauxfan | 31-Jul-10 - 04:54 AM ET |
| stokinpls | 31-Jul-10 - 06:23 AM ET |
| Pat Ireland | 31-Jul-10 - 07:56 AM ET |
| GROCERY GUY | 31-Jul-10 - 08:23 AM ET |
| hunter44 | 31-Jul-10 - 08:30 AM ET |
| shadow | 31-Jul-10 - 09:03 AM ET |
| bobdog | 31-Jul-10 - 09:18 AM ET |
| WPT | 31-Jul-10 - 11:04 AM ET |
| ALF-99 | 31-Jul-10 - 11:45 AM ET |
| Jerry Parr | 31-Jul-10 - 12:08 PM ET |
| dmarbell | 31-Jul-10 - 12:11 PM ET |
| b12 | 31-Jul-10 - 01:01 PM ET |
| walnutmaker | 31-Jul-10 - 01:54 PM ET |
| BigM-Perazzi | 31-Jul-10 - 02:32 PM ET |
| MTA Tom | 31-Jul-10 - 02:51 PM ET |
| dhip | 31-Jul-10 - 03:20 PM ET |
| BigM-Perazzi | 31-Jul-10 - 06:32 PM ET |
| Bernie K | 31-Jul-10 - 08:12 PM ET |
| dverna | 31-Jul-10 - 09:54 PM ET |
| jpollo | 01-Aug-10 - 01:36 AM ET |
| Stumpi24 | 01-Aug-10 - 10:19 AM ET |
| Mark T | 01-Aug-10 - 12:44 PM ET |
| BigM-Perazzi | 01-Aug-10 - 01:21 PM ET |
| WPT | 01-Aug-10 - 01:57 PM ET |
| Big Heap | 01-Aug-10 - 02:05 PM ET |
| hunter44 | 01-Aug-10 - 02:11 PM ET |
| Big Heap | 01-Aug-10 - 02:20 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 01-Aug-10 - 04:08 PM ET |
| Barry C. Roach | 01-Aug-10 - 07:10 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 01-Aug-10 - 07:17 PM ET |
| Barry C. Roach | 01-Aug-10 - 07:23 PM ET |
| HDLLLIII | 01-Aug-10 - 07:31 PM ET |
| BigM-Perazzi | 01-Aug-10 - 07:49 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 01-Aug-10 - 08:03 PM ET |
| HDLLLIII | 01-Aug-10 - 08:22 PM ET |
| HDLLLIII | 01-Aug-10 - 08:29 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 01-Aug-10 - 08:37 PM ET |
| blackfoot | 01-Aug-10 - 08:38 PM ET |
| BigM-Perazzi | 01-Aug-10 - 09:00 PM ET |
| bigdogtx | 01-Aug-10 - 09:00 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 01-Aug-10 - 10:04 PM ET |
| BigM-Perazzi | 01-Aug-10 - 10:32 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 01-Aug-10 - 11:13 PM ET |
| 1brucem | 01-Aug-10 - 11:22 PM ET |
| SilverShooter | 01-Aug-10 - 11:55 PM ET |
| Barry C. Roach | 02-Aug-10 - 01:14 AM ET |
| smoking357 | 02-Aug-10 - 01:26 AM ET |
| Barry C. Roach | 02-Aug-10 - 01:55 AM ET |
| smoking357 | 02-Aug-10 - 02:24 AM ET |
| Barry C. Roach | 02-Aug-10 - 02:31 AM ET |
| smoking357 | 02-Aug-10 - 09:26 AM ET |
| Barry C. Roach | 02-Aug-10 - 10:30 AM ET |
| 320090T | 02-Aug-10 - 11:01 AM ET |
| smoking357 | 02-Aug-10 - 11:05 AM ET |
| team henges | 02-Aug-10 - 11:06 AM ET |
| blackfoot | 02-Aug-10 - 12:52 PM ET |
| dmarbell | 02-Aug-10 - 02:31 PM ET |
| Bucko43 | 02-Aug-10 - 03:00 PM ET |
| blackfoot | 02-Aug-10 - 03:55 PM ET |
| targetmaster | 02-Aug-10 - 03:58 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 02-Aug-10 - 04:07 PM ET |
| targetmaster | 02-Aug-10 - 04:38 PM ET |
| Bucko43 | 02-Aug-10 - 04:41 PM ET |
| blackfoot | 02-Aug-10 - 06:07 PM ET |
| Maxum Moe | 02-Aug-10 - 06:55 PM ET |
| grnberetcj | 02-Aug-10 - 07:13 PM ET |
| targetmaster | 02-Aug-10 - 07:25 PM ET |
| Stumpi24 | 02-Aug-10 - 09:31 PM ET |
| dmarbell | 03-Aug-10 - 05:40 AM ET |
| blackfoot | 03-Aug-10 - 09:07 AM ET |
| smoking357 | 03-Aug-10 - 09:40 AM ET |
| GoldEx | 03-Aug-10 - 09:49 AM ET |
| smoking357 | 03-Aug-10 - 10:22 AM ET |
| ivanhoe | 03-Aug-10 - 12:01 PM ET |
| Big Heap | 03-Aug-10 - 12:04 PM ET |
| dickgtax | 03-Aug-10 - 12:14 PM ET |
| Pull & Mark | 03-Aug-10 - 12:20 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 03-Aug-10 - 12:34 PM ET |
| ivanhoe | 03-Aug-10 - 01:08 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 03-Aug-10 - 01:33 PM ET |
| Neil Winston | 03-Aug-10 - 01:41 PM ET |
| Big Heap | 03-Aug-10 - 01:44 PM ET |
| ivanhoe | 03-Aug-10 - 01:46 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 03-Aug-10 - 02:46 PM ET |
| ivanhoe | 03-Aug-10 - 03:40 PM ET |
| GoldEx | 03-Aug-10 - 04:00 PM ET |
| ivanhoe | 03-Aug-10 - 04:41 PM ET |
| Jack Frost | 03-Aug-10 - 04:47 PM ET |
| smoking357 | 03-Aug-10 - 04:53 PM ET |
| FlaLagarto | 03-Aug-10 - 06:10 PM ET |
| slugbug1 | 03-Aug-10 - 06:54 PM ET |
| jbbor | 03-Aug-10 - 07:46 PM ET |
| jbbor | 03-Aug-10 - 07:54 PM ET |
| dmarbell | 03-Aug-10 - 10:54 PM ET |
| Barry C. Roach | 03-Aug-10 - 11:18 PM ET |
| GoldEx | 04-Aug-10 - 08:58 AM ET |
| WPT | 04-Aug-10 - 09:52 AM ET |
Why when our contract is up at sparta could we not have the Grand American trap shoot at The Cardinal Center, then Las Vegas then back at sparta, and do a three year rotation,that would make our Ohio people happy and our western people happy and our mid-america people happy, sparta is a great place but what a undeveloped area, I was fortunate enough to be in a shoot off the last two years, done shooting by four and sat in the bar until nine until shootoff time, motel a hour away,this sucks.
Better yet, why not just let each state hold their own Grand on a rotating basis?
Every 50 years your state would be happy.......or not.
I think having a travelling Grand American is a great idea. There are so many beautiful facilities that could/would expand to house the Grand. If it rotated, then people from all over the country that may not be familiar with the event would stop in and see what it was all about.....hmmmm, maybe a way to increase our membership? I think so.
The reason is that you cannot possibly justify the expense (at Sparta in excess of 50 million) unless you can secure annual attendance for an extended period. Anything else makes no sense at all.
Another reason is that some places are better than others, and Sparta is the best so why go elsewhere?
Neil
and it still dwarfs on a 2 week stage anything else around.
2006 - Quite a site.....
FRedmon
I certainly think it is a good idea, but I live in California, so Las Vegas is a 4 hr. drive. The mid-west has dominated the Grand American with their participation and shorter drives in RV's. It is expensive to fly out and bring your equipment or drive an RV for 3 days. Accommodations at Sparta "suck" unless you have an RV. Thus much of the Western part of the country is cut off. Sparta was a very selfish decision. Fred
Great idea, Stumpi. No reason a big event can't rotate. The Super Bowl does. The All Star game does.
I can't believe they'd stick they'd stick the big event somewhere I can't get a hotel and see a horse race. I can't do guns all day and all night.
Cardinal Center does not have enough traps (at one time with a nod and a wink there would have been) for the Grand. And Vegas is too far away from the ATA shooter base.
Too many deals made with the Sparta site. The ATA has made their last stand there win or lose. Let's hope it has a better result than the one Custer had.
Rock
Jim
Selfish on whose part Fred?
Yeah, Custer, another famous Ohioan.....
Saw a bumper sticker on a pink Cadillac once driven by a Lakota--it said: Custer had it coming! Sparta win or lose! Poor decision in my book!
Lets have a telephonic shoot like they do for the zones or maybe everybody could just shoot where ever they wanted and call in the scores its all computerized anyway. LOL
Stumpi24- It seems to me an air-conditioned phone booth for you and all your friends, would have solved your problem.
My point again, the main base will travel to the grand where ever it is, lets help the people living in other areas make it to the grand. And no one will dispute the facilities at Sparta, but it dam sure stops there, if you are not camping you are very inconvenienced and again if you want to watch or are in a shoot off and not camping this place sucks. I am told the venders are going to be at one end and the shooters at the other.
I thought this had been beaten to death a couple times already on this site....the huge majority of shooters are in the east. Lots bitched when they had to drive a little further west to Sparta...and could care less about how far anybody else has to travel....I'd have a 3 day drive (from Alberta) and I'll probably never get there....fact O' life....
Would someone please explain what good is a shooting facilty capable of handling a 4000 shooter event as was the case in Vandalia and in Sparta yet only has the infrastructure to handle less than 2000 as has been the case in Sparta???????
What is wrong with this picture?? I ask-- maybe someone can answer this?
There is no correct answer. Phil S.
Same old, same old.........stuff........
Got it now?
Hauxfan!
How about having the Grand at a different local club every year. The size of the club would determine how long it took to run all of the entrants through. Some trap clubs could shoot every day of their year, and maybe around the clock. Eventually everyone would be served. Shooters could be given a date and time to show up ("Presquadding") and that way the local infrastructure could handle the influx. The vendors could set up on the grounds August 1 and stay all year selling like mad! Why didn't we think of this back in 2000?
Sorry, just getting "Grand Fever". ;-)
Good idea- Rotate the Grand among the sites large enough to hold the Grand. At this time, that would mean Sparta every year. If some of the posters could convince their state to spend about 30 million to build a large gun club, then we would have another choice. I would love to see several gun clubs with more than 100 traps across the country. But now, we only have one.
Pat Ireland
I think the Rock is right, to many deals made. Glenn Allison
Would you & or the rock please share some specifics concerning any "deals" made. Only specifics please, no second hand info. or hearsay.
Fron the tone of other threads it couldbe that some of the "good ole boys" may need a trip to Illinois to confer with the politicians there.
Must be August...
The Grand at Sparta has not secured an annual attendance ... The figures that have been posted say the attendance has been dropping off every year which makes Sparta just as bad of a choice now just as it was 5 years ago when the Grand was first held there ... Those involved will never live up to or admit to the fact that they blew it when they made the choice to move to Sparta, Illinois but the numbers do not lie no matter how you bend them ... Sparta was and is the begining of the end for the ATA unless they make some definitive changes real soon, starting with the EC and all the others involved in the Good Ol" Boys Club ...
If the Grand was an invitational shoot, no options and all money must be played in each event entered it would in fact draw all of the best shooters from all over the world and eliminate those who go to just say they were there and have peach ice cream ... This would also eliminate the need for a 3 1/2 mile trapline and 120 traps which do not get used any way because the attendance does not warrant it ... The shoot could be held at places where they do have accomidations readily available and in place, on less traps and people wouldn't have to tour the State of Illinois every day going back and forth to the place where you are staying ... The Grand would once again be "The Grand" and the money would make it worth while shooting for those who really are the best and put the money down as proof of it .... WPT ... (YAC) ...
Build it and they will come . Or my favorite So don,t come and WE will take your place ??
....couple more years of the Grand at Sparta and 40 traps will do just fine....mark my words.....Jerry
Neil Winston, played by Gerard Butler. Persian Messenger, played by dissenters of Sparta.
Snicker.
Danny
I could see why some of the people from larger cities complain about the accomaditions at and around the Grand. They are used to about any convience at hand. And that is ok. However the people from small towns and rual areas are used to an hrs drive about in any direction for anything. Sparta has done a good job to accomadate the shooter. Just my opinon. I don't think sparta in the beginning was a good place to have it. It is in a anti-gun state no matter how you look at it. Chicago is so corrupted that the control has spilled out into all counties. On that matter we should not give them any business of the sport. But so is Vegas so what is the difference. Just an extension of the other hand.
But at least it is in one place so many people can plan way ahead to go if they feel they can afford it. The Grand only gets a few of the trap shooters around the U.S. because a large percentage cannot afford to make the long trip and take the time off work. Especially now days. You can see many of the people that come to the grand like to exploit their wealth or have much time on their hands so they can afford to go anyway.
What I think could be done is to have state champions of each shoot at the grand for the biggest prize. That way many people that don't normally shoot at the grand might be able to finally compete for the big one. I know this would probobaly cut down on the once a year attendance but it would give a chance for the little guy to get a shot for all the marbles. Its just a thought.
I think Jerry Parr has it about right! I doubt-- judging by the fact that until this week hotels could be had near the shoot-- that the $100,000.00 will cause a giant increase in attendance. Thanks so much to the Martins for trying but it probably won't help.
4000 enrties in any of the caps! Nahhh. Phil S.
No singles, doubles and 27 yd caps only. It can move to Mason, Michigan...
then I will only drive the 35 miles....
Jim, it was discussed with the ATA.
How about the NEW Automated trap range being built in PA.,,It shoild be big enough,and I'm sure being automated and Ultr modern technology things would run real smooth...LMAO
Doug H.
Well then Tom. Only if they bring the vendors along....
Putting my Sparta-or-Bust sticker on my car now....
Just checked the weather for next week, Tues. 97, Wed. 97. Right noe Sat. night 8pm 86 feels like 95. Looks like another " Hot Grand".
I think Custer came from Michigan. State of the doomed.
Anyway, Sparta will not survive in the long run. There are not enough shoots to support the place.
With our association losing $400k per year there is no way we can afford to find another venue if we must pay for it. Shoot attendance will continue to drop. So it will need a place that can handle 1500 or so shooters.
Look at the age of our shooters. More and more dying off, more and more are not shooting due to age, and/or the economy. We will NEVER see a 5000 person Grand again.
With fewer shooters a place like the Cardinal Center makes a lot of sense.
Increase the costs to make the event profitable and limit attendance to 1500 (heck we are almost there now) and you don't need 3 miles of trap fields (didn't we only use 18 fields last year?) You guys who think we need $4 practice rounds to save the sport are never going to make it. The guys with $100k+ RV's, and $20k guns are calling the shots.
Think about it. Wouldn't you rather spend $40/100 for targets in Ohio than $33/100 if you did not have drive an extra 300+ miles each way to get there; and stay 45 miles each away every day to find a decent hotel? You see, the RV'ers don't care. It is the poor Joe slobs who suffer.
But the Grand is in Sparta now; so stop bitching and shoot at a great place. Take lots of photos so you can show your grandkids what once was. When it is gone, there will never be another place like it. Enjoy it while we can.
Don Verna
The majority of shooters are in 5 or 6 states , move the grand to Ohio, PA, Mi NY Il IN
Yes Don I agree with you onehundred percent I bought a camper this year but the last one's I did not, as I said in the earlier statement this place is a gem in a sewer hole, if you are in a shoot off good luck standing around for 4 to 5 hours and if you want to watch shoot offs again you stand around, get some amenities or get it out of there, everyone says in fifteen years it will be fine, will most of us do not have the time to plant small trees.
The comment about Cardinal Center not having enough traps to hold the grand is valid. However, if there was an agreement to hold the Grand there they have more than enough room to add traps to hold the Grand. The original plans allowed for up to 120 traps. If it were to move to Cardinal Mr. Fishburn and his people don't let grass grow under their feet and they could have enough traps for the Grand. But after how they treated him when he offered to have the Hall of Fame there I think the ATA would have to do some major but kissing for him to let them use his shooting facility.
Actually Don, Custer was indeed born in Ohio...
If they increased the CC to 120 traps, would Mr Fishburn build the hotels/motels needed? or would we have to drive from Findlay or Columbus every day?
If the Grand was someplace, anyplace other than Sparta, Illinois they might need more traps than they already have at the Cardinal Center but they sure as hell wouldn't need a 120 of them and a trapline thats 3 1/2 miles long ... Then the ATA could sell the traps and recoup some of the money that came out of the relocation fund fees that all members paid into ... Maybe Illinois would buy them being as they said they were going to build the WSRC even if the ATA didn't commit to moving the Grand there ... WPT ... (YAC) ...
Come and Prepare to be Thrilled!
Las Vegas is where the stars come to play and they love to play with us! Who knows whom you might see. We are frequented by movie stars, sports figures, models, and local personalities. Come catch a glimpse of some of the beautiful people you may see here at our unique and exciting establishment complete with 120 traps.
And lots of hotel rooms!
And daytime heat index in Las Vagas in August is what?
During the reorganization of the ATA, the August date for the old traditional Grand will be set with consideration of current conditions.
Vegas is an excellent idea, but not every year.
Vegas in November is lovely. Atlanta in November is pretty nice, too. Can that Olympic course be used? The location has to be a place that is enjoyable to everyone, even in complete absence of shooting.
This sport really needs a pro shooters tour.
S357 - your continued lack of knowledge about ATA shooting continues to astound us.
Barry, you're badly missing the point and saying some goofy things.
This discussion is about weather and logistics. Do you have some alternate weather database that shows Midwestern weather in August is lovely and Southern weather in November is horrible?
Do you have a map that shows Sparta is a 1 million+ city?
Come on, Barry. Get with it.
S357 - Do you have an alternative venue for the Grand? Until then, your out of gas.
It never ceases to amaze me how many people complain about things that appear to work. 15,000 hotel rooms, 5 star restraunts,shopping,movies, even strip clubs, within an hours drive. If the Grand was held in there hometown ot backyard the complaints would be: Too much traffic, motorhomes in the way, too much noise...etc. The economy certainly would not have anything to do with the reduced attendance...Larry Lockhar
Right! And in the middle of November, December or January, I'm going to get out my trapgun that I've been shooting wearing a down jacket with, and spend my money to fly to Las Vegas...
The way it is now, it's pretty much the perfect end to the trapseason.....
It is not an hour from Sparta to St. Louis. It's about 1.5 hours. Sparta is 55 miles from St. Louis, and it isn't even on an Interstate. In fact, the entire route from Sparta to St. Louis is completed without the benefit of a single Interstate leg, leaving a driver to be at the prey of merciless Illinois State Police and predator small-town Illinois police departments.
Worse, Illinois cops openly hate guns and look to make as many gun arrests as possible. You're rolling the dice with your freedom if you travel in or through Illinois with a gun.
Have a look at this wonderful Illinois law:
720 ILCS 5/24?1
(a) A person commits the offense of unlawful use of weapons when he knowingly:
(4) Carries or possesses in any vehicle or concealed on or about his person except when on his land or in his own abode or fixed place of business any pistol, revolver, stun gun or taser or other firearm, except that this subsection (a) (4) does not apply to or affect transportation of weapons that meet one of the following conditions: (i) are broken down in a non?functioning state; or (ii) are not immediately accessible; or (iii) are unloaded and enclosed in a case, firearm carrying box, shipping box, or other container by a person who has been issued a currently valid Firearm Owner's Identification Card; or
...
(8) Carries or possesses any firearm, stun gun or taser or other deadly weapon in any place which is licensed to sell intoxicating beverages, or at any public gathering held pursuant to a license issued by any governmental body or any public gathering at which an admission is charged, excluding a place where a showing, demonstration or lecture involving the exhibition of unloaded firearms is conducted.
(9) Carries or possesses in a vehicle or on or about his person any pistol, revolver, stun gun or taser or firearm or ballistic knife, when he is hooded, robed or masked in such manner as to conceal his identity; or
(10) Carries or possesses on or about his person, upon any public street, alley, or other public lands within the corporate limits of a city, village or incorporated town, except when an invitee thereon or therein, for the purpose of the display of such weapon or the lawful commerce in weapons, or except when on his land or in his own abode or fixed place of business, any pistol, revolver, stun gun or taser or other firearm, except that this subsection (a) (10) does not apply to or affect transportation of weapons that meet one of the following conditions: (i) are broken down in a non?functioning state; or (ii) are not immediately accessible; or (iii) are unloaded and enclosed in a case, firearm carrying box, shipping box, or other container by a person who has been issued a currently valid Firearm Owner's Identification Card.
(b) Sentence. A person convicted of a violation of subsection 24?1(a)(1) through (5), subsection 24?1(a)(10), subsection 24?1(a)(11), or subsection 24?1(a)(13) commits a Class A misdemeanor. A person convicted of a violation of subsection 24?1(a)(8) or 24?1(a)(9) commits a Class 4 felony; a person convicted of a violation of subsection 24?1(a)(6) or 24?1(a)(7)(ii) or (iii) commits a Class 3 felony. A person convicted of a violation of subsection 24?1(a)(7)(i) commits a Class 2 felony and shall be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of not less than 3 years and not more than 7 years, unless the weapon is possessed in the passenger compartment of a motor vehicle as defined in Section 1?146 of the Illinois Vehicle Code, or on the person, while the weapon is loaded, in which case it shall be a Class X felony. A person convicted of a second or subsequent violation of subsection 24?1(a)(4), 24?1(a)(8), 24?1(a)(9), or 24?1(a)(10) commits a Class 3 felony. The possession of each weapon in violation of this Section constitutes a single and separate violation.
...
Bottom line, folks, when you bring a gun into Illinois, you're completely at the mercy of a cop construing your transit as a violation of 720 ILCS 5/24?1 and charging you with a felony.
Oh, and the penalties increase if you should make the mistake of pulling into a parking lot at one of these locations: "in any school, regardless of the time of day or the time of year, in residential property owned, operated or managed by a public housing agency or leased by a public housing agency as part of a scattered site or mixed?income development, in a public park, in a courthouse, on the real property comprising any school, regardless of the time of day or the time of year, on residential property owned, operated or managed by a public housing agency or leased by a public housing agency as part of a scattered site or mixed?income development, on the real property comprising any public park, on the real property comprising any courthouse, in any conveyance owned, leased or contracted by a school to transport students to or from school or a school related activity, in any conveyance owned, leased, or contracted by a public transportation agency, or on any public way within 1,000 feet of the real property comprising any school, public park, courthouse, public transportation facility, or residential property owned, operated, or managed by a public housing agency or leased by a public housing agency as part of a scattered site or mixed?income development." Stop at any of these places, and it's a Class 2 felony, and you shall be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of not less than 3 years and not more than 7 years.
Be careful where you pull over to check your map or get another Coke from the cooler. You're one hungry cop's police report away from having your life destroyed.
It was the biggest, dumbest mistake to put a gun event in a state in which the cops make their living preying on gun owners.
Smoking357 you seem a tad paranoid to me. Thank you for citing Illinois law regarding firearms and transportation thereof. Would you kindly provide us with the statutes that apply to Ohio,Indiana,Missouri,Kentucky,California,Nevada, what the heck how about the other 49 states and U S territories for transportation of firearms. Also please provide accurate documentation of the hundreds of trapshooters who have been charged with felonies going to the Grand in Sparta for the last couple of years. btw if it takes you 1.5 hours to drive to the hotel rooms and eateries i would respectfully suggest shifting from 2nd gear into 3rd or maybe even use drive. Larry Lockhart
Smoking357 you seem a tad paranoid to me. Thank you for citing Illinois law regarding firearms and transportation thereof. Would you kindly provide us with the statutes that apply to Ohio,Indiana,Missouri,Kentucky,California,Nevada, what the heck how about the other 49 states and U S territories for transportation of firearms. Also please provide accurate documentation of the hundreds of trapshooters who have been charged with felonies going to the Grand in Sparta for the last couple of years. btw if it takes you 1.5 hours to drive to the hotel rooms and eateries i would respectfully suggest shifting from 2nd gear into 3rd or maybe even use drive. Larry Lockhart
HD, I'm not worried about the gun laws in Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, or Nevada.
To add to the above, Trapshooters are gun owners. It was utterly foolish to put a gun event somewhere the gunnies couldn't OC or CC.
VEGAS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
.357
'ILLINOIS— Possession of a firearm or ammunition generally requires an Illinois Firearm Owner’s Identification Card (FOID). This requirement does not apply, however, to nonresidents whose firearms are unloaded or enclosed in a case. The possession of a firearm in a vehicle is also generally prohibited, but this restriction does not apply to firearms that are “broken down in a non-functioning state” or that are not immediately accessible.'
And, are you familiar with the Firearms Owners’ Protection Act? We resolved these issues 5 years ago...
I would bet there is an "agreement" of some sort of remuneration to the State of Illinois for the building of this facility. If it is to move, the agreement will have to have ended.
You didn't "resolve" anything, BigM. All the FOPA gives you is an affirmative defense upon which you bear the burden of proof. The State's Attorney can still destroy your life while you try to win on procedure.
I notice you didn't come near my point about OC and CC.
I might stop by the Grand, but I won't have a gun or a round anywhere in my car.
Y'all can play that lottery.
I can't believe a gun organization rewarded one of the most anti-gun states in the union with a big gun event.
smokin, go stick it. It's old. As I told you, but you weren't listening, it was resolved years ago. And as far as OC or CC.. I just look at Fort Hood and say it doesn't matter where...
Just stay away, that's my best suggestion.
BigM, you're a very rude man. You think you're an expert on gun laws, and when you're contradicted, you respond with insult. That's very rude and very immature.
Nothing is "resolved." You've just accepted the bad reality. Either that, or you've deluded yourself about the law. Please don't try to convince anyone here that firearms travel in or through Illinois is "safe."
If you travel with a gun, lock that gun in the trunk, and make sure that your hand can't reach into the trunk area, as with a hatchback, van or an SUV. Unload the gun. Disassemble the gun, if possible, and lock the gun case.
I'd recommend following this and keeping a copy of it with you while you're in Illinois.:
http://www.gsldefensetraining.com/images/transportinglegally.pdf
Wouldn't it be nice if the ATA put this event somewhere we didn't have to worry about this?
Sounds like the Cardinal Classic is becoming the shadow Grand.
I think all the western states should withdraw from the ATA. This post proves that we are considered irrelevant. PITA is waiting for us and ATA doesn't value us. Bruce
The sport is fragmenting and dying as proven by attendance. Sadly there is no executive level road map for the next generation of shooters. AIM is great but thats for the 2nd and 3rd generations not the next generation. The next generation will be mostly men who are currently in their thirties, forties and early fifties now. Currently, the majority are mostly old guys waiting to die, and they will take the sport with them, Sorry if I hurt you feelings.
There should be three or four regional divisions like west, central, south and east -- and the grand should rotate thru all. The grand could then be invitational and/or based on wins, scores and averages or other criteria -- that would encourage a pro circuit.
...but until someone or some group start thinking about the future, it will staty the same and slowly peeter out...
S357 - It is you that have been rude......and right from the start. Spew your vitriol elsewhere unless you've run out of stones to hide under.
Barry, I just finished reading that marathon thread about Sparta being doomed in which WPT whooped you and revealed that you were from Illinois.
'Nuff said about your motivations.
You were nothing but rude and insulting to him, too.
I've been around for a long time S357. Over 45 years of registered trap shooting. WPT also told me that the Grand would never be in Illinois on this site so that pretty much tells you who was right there. But it's not about being right in your case.
You can't come onto an internet site as well developed as this one and as ignorant as you are and try to argue cases that have been mulled over and over until they are old history. Just reading old posts don't give you the whole story. What is written on TS.Com is akin to reading The Inquirer. Some of it is true and factual and some is baloney.
You are attempting to be a provocateur. You have proven through your writings that you are new to trapshooting and have only a rudimentary knowlegde of the history of the sport. I'm sure you've heard the phrase "If you can't dazzle them with brilliance then baffle them with bullshit." So far all we've heard from you is the latter.
Quit hiding behind "tradition," Barry.
Come up with something, once in a while, that actually holds its own as an argument.
All you're doing is trying to squelch ideas with which you disagree.
Give me tradition anytime.
"Give me tradition anytime."
Finally, you understand why it needs to return to Ohio.
Finally we know your real adenda. Just another Ohio or nothing guy. You finally trapped yourself.
I don't care where the Grand is, I'm going. Illinois, Ohio, Nevada, Indiana, Mississippi, where ever! You guys can fuss till the cows come home, or just go shoot.
Barry, you're not making sense.
Ohio is a great choice. So is Indiana. Kentucky is a fine option.
Many options make sense. Evidently, you completely ignored my posts above which spoke well of November shoots in Atlanta and Vegas.
There are some choices that will just never be right. Illinois is high on that list, and other choices that force large numbers of shooters to drive through Illinois are also iffy.
I agree with 320090T, I dont care where the grand is IM GOING. And where else is there that many trap fields and a facility that nice to accomodate that many people?
I will never go to Sparta and will join the THOUSANDS of ATA members West of the Miss. who will never attend.The Grand is a shoot for the Midwest and those who live and travel the country in RV's.Look at the Grand attendance #'s: it's going down,the boys are getting older, and the midwest/Pa are the major attendee's.
It's a big country and we in the West do matter and hope in my lifetime that there will be a Grand Western shoot for ATA/PITA members in Vegas.They can handle 10,000 shooters and the state of Nevada built their new facility for a shoot on a national scale and would welcome a shoot like the Grand( Nevada is gun friendly)
If the ATA is in fact in finacial trouble( the #'s look like it to me). They need to grow from where they are now and at the same time control expenses.
The future growth needs to come from the West which is a shooter's market. Look at the size and growth of western shoots- they are showing growth.
The Cardinal and Sparta guys can fight it out - but this Westerner looks forward to shooting VEGAS!
http://www.isp.state.il.us/foid/firearmsfaq.cfm
If a non-resident is coming to Illinois to hunt and would like to bring their firearm, how do they legally transport it? Non- residents must be legally eligible to possess or acquire firearms and ammunition in their state of residence. It is recommended that, in order to be in compliance with all statutes, non-residents transport all firearms: 1) Unloaded, and 2) Enclosed in a case, and 3) Not immediately accessible or broken down in a nonfunctioning state. (dmarbell added the numbers for easier reading, as the format did not copy.)
From the document that smoking357 linked to:
In order to comply with those statutes when transporting a firearm, it must be: 1. Unloaded, and 2. Enclosed in a case, and 3. By persons who have a valid FOID card. 4. Non-Residents must be eligible to possess or acquire firearms and ammunition in their state of residence.
There is nothing unsettled about this part of Illinois law. The only caveat is traveling through nutcase Illinois municipalities that ban guns.
To resolve this issue: There are about 3,000 shooters a year (?) shooting at the Grand. How many out-of-state-of-Illinois shooters have had legal problems involving transporting firearms? If you have, let's hear it.
Many shooters fly in with their guns. If they weren't supposed to have guns in Illinois, do you think they'd be allowed to leave the airports?
Also, based on what I've been able to determine, the rear storage part of a hatchback or SUV is not considered to be accessible to drivers or front seat passengers.
smoking357, I hate to enter this fray. Spend some time figuring out how to get 45 mph clay targets to show up on television, and our sports can take their places in popularity behind televised hockey.
Danny, The Bored
I agree with Blackfoot, Vegas would be a great spot. But I have another suggestion. Why not have (3) clubs rotate every year.
For example, year one is Sparta, year two is Vegas, year three is a club located closer to the East coast (Pennsylvania?).
At least that way the folks on either coast can attend once every three years.
Another suggestion is why don't they let the cities bid on holding the Grand like they do with the Olympics? That way the city that has it in (3) years can start building their complex...
Kevin
Kevin, that is an outstanding suggestion!I think rotating the Grand would be a solution to everyone's needs and would breathe some life into the ATA- the board would be forced to address the needs of the membership at large!
I vote to have it at the Silver Dollar in Florida!
I like the Vegas plan, and I like rotation.
I really like moving it later in the year, too.
Silver Dollar is a nice facility, but it's very South in the country, and I don't think that two-lane road could handle the traffic. Silver Dollar is another 500 miles PAST ATLANTA, and Atlanta is considered the Deep South!
How about alternating Grands between Vegas and Atlanta, in November, annually? The Midwest and East Coast can reasonably reach Atlanta, and the West Coast guys can hike it to Vegas.
When they hold it in Vegas, can we please throw the lime targets?
I do Love those green targets
The turnout from California, Oregon, Washington, Nevada, Arizona and Idaho shooters could be a very large crowd. Most of these folks normally wouldn't drive 3 days to get to the Grand, especially if they are not retired. But anything within a days drive, I would be there in a heart beat.
Kevin
You need to Add Montana,Wyoming,Arizona,New Mexico,Colorado,Utah and Texas to the Western bunch!The numbers start to add up!
Las Vegas is the best place to hold the Grand. If you need something to compare it to look at the PRCA NFR. They had a 5 year deal with Vegas in 1985 and it has not left. Why? It is a place that the whole family can go and enjoy. The other reason is the money that the city has put in the event. Just something to look at and think about.
Build a trapshooting/sc/skeet/bunker, etc, etc., near the Cheney Reservoir (10 miles) west of Wichita,KS. That venue is approx 1300 miles east of Sacramento, CA and approx 1300 miles west Filthydephia,PA.
As long as we're wishing in one and crapping in the other.....this would be a ideal "central Location".
A better solution would be to partner with Bass pro Shops and build something near Bransom, MO. Plenty to do for everyone.
Or
Find a state that is not going bankrupt.
Curt
Lets have a playoff on the East and West coast with only the winners advancing to a neutral site in the middle. might make everyone be able to attend.
Thanks everyone for the discussion on this subject, I feel everyone has a good opinion on this subject, there is no reason why we can't have this shoot in three different areas of the country, the main base shooters will attend anywhere the shoot is held, this would give the rest of the country a chance to shoot at the grand, I would like to see other area's of the country anyway. Thanks Stan
Stan,
Only one thing would stop the Grand from rotating. The $50 million or so investment required to create facilities like Sparta, while having the promise to have 2,500 or more shooters once every three years (see Neil's comment near the top of the thread). And if the goal is to increase attendance, there have to be three facilities capable of handling even more shooters than Sparta.
The Super Bowl can rotate because there are many stadiums in large cities capable of handing 100,000 fans.
Danny
Las Vegas is already built-brand new,the 10,000 high quality rooms(probably at an attractive price) are made up and ready within 10 miles, the highways are in place,the airport can move 100,000 people/day 15 miles down the road,and enough RV sites for all and probably more potential prize money available than anyone can imagine.
It lacks one thing- the shoot!Why would anyone want to shoot there-maybe no trees,no humidty?
Can we get the Barbary Coast or the 'Dust to put up a line?
We'll see how good these shooters really are when there's action being taken on them.
I can see nothing wrong with Vegas in November. The pro class can even get television coverage.
With the current trend in our membership numbers, there are several facilities in existence right now that can accomodate a rotating Grand. Missouri, Cardinal Center, Sparta, Michigan and Nevada are the big 5 that come to mind. If there are any more clubs with at least 40 program traps I would include them as well as long as all of the traps face the same direction. It would take a huge increase in shooters before 40 traps was insufficient. 20 - 2 trap banks, proven to speed up the shooting process due to less moving. No partial squads allowed. Except for the last flight. Again, think outside the box. Partial squads are wasteful and disrupt the flow of the event.
I can't see any new facilities being built from the ground up to house a tournament that would occur once every 3 years at best so the only other solution is to add on to some of the larger clubs that may already have the available space for additinal field to attain the 40 program trap minimum. That would broaden the pool of locations a bunch.
The age old excuse of the Grand being held in the summer because thats when "the kids" were out of school is a big crock of doo doo. There would be no problem getting responsible adults to score and load machines anywhere the event was held if necessary. Stop using "The Kids" as your excuse. If the sport is important enough, "The Kids" will get time off of school and go. My dad didn't have a problem pulling me out of school for a week or more to go to deer camp as long as my grades were up and I got my homework assignments in advance so please don't go there. It's just an excuse. Find a new one.
Saying that the Grand needs to be held at the end of the target year is also a bunch of crap. People whine, people cry, people stomp their feet and they get their way. It's time to slap them and stick them in the corner for awhile until they get over their little tantrums. What difference does it matter when it's held? The requirements to participate are for target year X, regardless of when the event is held. Again, another big excuse.
Successful businesses adapt to market conditions to survive. Those that do it well prosper. Those that don't flounder and wither and die a slow painful death. Sounds like the ATA is in the withering and dying category. Too caught up in their old ways to adapt and it is slowly dying. Unless there are some big changes to "Business as Usual", there isn't going to be any business to worry about.
Jeff
Awesome post, Gold Ex. Unfortunately, they'll just hide behind claims of "you just don't understand the traditions of the sport" and claim that if you haven't actually won the Grand, you have no business talking about it.
Before I post this I would like to say I really didn't intend to start a pi**ing contest in this thread but it would appear that I will be a little late. Toking357 please don't start you tactics of changing the subject when someone nails you BS to the wall as you always do. Just think about what I am going to tell you.
"Great idea, Stumpi. No reason a big event can't rotate. The Super Bowl does. The All Star game does."
So tell us where do they hold them??? You always seem to compare Multi million dollar sports with sports that rely on $100,000 donations to try to boost attendance.
"Vegas in November is lovely. Atlanta in November is pretty nice, too. Can that Olympic course be used? The location has to be a place that is enjoyable to everyone, even in complete absence of shooting."
Absolutely there is nothing I would like better than to go to Vegas or Atlanta just to have lovely weather even if I don't shoot. RIGHT!!!!!!
"This discussion is about weather and logistics. Do you have some alternate weather database that shows Midwestern weather in August is lovely and Southern weather in November is horrible?"
See my comment above it fits the drivel also. I was under the impression that the discussion was about having different locations for the Grand!!!!!!
"HD, I'm not worried about the gun laws in Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, or Nevada."
This one is interesting you are worried about gun laws in IL. Yet not in any of the states the people have to drive through to get to IL or to venues that may be in those states. So it would seem that you are only interested in disrupting the flow of the conversation in progress.
"I can't believe a gun organization rewarded one of the most anti-gun states in the union with a big gun event."
Toking 357 you have this incorrect the ATA didn't reward IL. They rewarded the ATA they paid the bill for Sparta to the tune of 30 plus million dollars. Of I know that you think that is chicken feed for an Association that is loosing money annually. As a matter of fact it appears some others Sparta bashers do also.
"BigM, you're a very rude man. You think you're an expert on gun laws, and when you're contradicted, you respond with insult. That's very rude and very immature."
Well gee toker if he thinks he is and expert on gun laws and you are contradicting him that would make you the expert!!! Just as the fact that you seem to think you arean expert on guns, weather, gun clubs and of course Trap. YA RIGHT!!!!!!!!!! Why would the state of IL spend 30 plus million on a shooting facility run by the state and then allow the police in that state to drive the shooters away? Brilliant deduction on your part but why would logic come from the vast cavern you call a head. YES I am being rude.
"Barry, I just finished reading that marathon thread about Sparta being doomed in which WPT whooped you and revealed that you were from Illinois."
Toker that is no revelation anyone that has been here longer than a month and isn't an expert on every subject known to man. Has known all along where Barry comes from. BTW where does WPT come from, not where does he live where does he come from.
"Come up with something, once in a while, that actually holds its own as an argument."
Does that statement mean the winning the argument is more important than discussing the issues. As your comments put you in an argument every thread you post on. I would guess you have to win something.
"Finally, you understand why it needs to return to Ohio."
No please tell us how returning to Ohio will restore tradition at a club that maybe didn't exist while the grand was in Ohio. Or at least not on the scale it does now. BTW the club that was tridition in Ohio no longer exists.
"Ohio is a great choice. So is Indiana. Kentucky is a fine option.
So outside of the possibility of Ohio can you name a club in Indiana or Kentucky that is big enough to host the Grand????
"Many options make sense. Evidently, you completely ignored my posts above which spoke well of November shoots in Atlanta and Vegas."
Well Vegas might but which club in Atlanta?????
"How about alternating Grands between Vegas and Atlanta, in November, annually? The Midwest and East Coast can reasonably reach Atlanta, and the West Coast guys can hike it to Vegas."
Again which club in Atlanta?????
"I can see nothing wrong with Vegas in November. The pro class can even get television coverage."
Try to understand "There is no Pro Class" so what would TV cover?????????
GoldEx if attendance is down at the Grand in Sparta can you guarantee that 40 traps will be enough at the more desirable locations that you sight????
Bob Lawless
"Defunct athletics competitions" The following 8 pages are in this category, out of 8 total. This list may not reflect recent changes ().
A IAAF Golden League
E European Cup (athletics)
G IAAF Grand Prix Final
G cont. The Greatest Race on Earth
U UK Championships in Athletics
W IAAF World Athletics Final
ATA -GAH?
I started shooting trap in Illinois in 1970. In 40 years I have not heard of a single incident of a trapshooter being harassed, threatened, arrested,or anything similar in connection with going to, coming from, or attending a trapshoot. Yeah, Illinois is really against trapshooting.
Ok, so maybe they move the Grand to Oct. why not have it in more than one place and make it like the Satilite Grand. One in Sparta,the other in Vegas, with maybe a 3rd in San Anton. or maybe just the two. Just a thought. Break-em all. Jeff
"Just think about what I am going to tell you."
No. You're wasting my time, and you're wrong. I posted the solutions, and you're ignoring them, asking me to explain myself, all over again. No, thanks. I'm not going to do all the work, twice.
By the way, Indiana, Ohio and Kentucky don't require the East Coasters to drive through Illinois. That's why they were mentioned, and that's why Missouri was omitted. Branson would be a very decent location, if not for the act of bringing a gun into Illinois. Vegas was included because it's probably the best place to hold the event, and it's time to show some respect to the West Coasters. East Coasters can drop down and avoid Illinois, altogether, on their way to Vegas. Many will fly and skip right over it.
Returning to Ohio makes sense and holds to the tradition, even if the prior club is gone.
I don't understand this sentence:
"there is nothing I would like better than to go to Vegas or Atlanta just to have lovely weather even if I don't shoot. RIGHT!!!!!! "
You are the master of avoiding what you have said like changing the subject like you have done with this one,
"No. You're wasting my time, and you're wrong. I posted the solutions, and you're ignoring them, asking me to explain myself, all over again. No, thanks. I'm not going to do all the work, twice.
You posted the solutions so tell us what clubs in Atlanta are large enough to hold the Grand??? How about Kentucky, Indiana or any of the other states you mentioned how many gun clubs in those states are large enough to host the Grand??? Your the one making up the solutions how about some useful facts that you haven't provided???
I will now change the subject you think you have all the answers. Well you have none you are by far the biggest BLOW HARD that has ever been on this site. You insult all shooters that post here most of whom have many, many more years, hours, minutes of experience than you will have ten years from now.
Yet those facts mean nothing to you your head is so inflated that to you your opinion is the only one that counts. I might add that the same head is so empty I surprised that when you open your mouth there isn't an echo.
I think there is only one solution you could come up with and I am not allowed to elaborate on the method of acquiring it on this site.
Bob Lawless
"You insult all shooters that post here most of whom have many, many more years, hours, minutes of experience than you will have ten years from now."
I'll probably be here ten years from now, too. Are you under 40? If not, your group is going to move out of the way, and new people and ideas are going to take over. Vegas has been repeatedly suggested. This is an attractive option for a lot of people. It will probably happen, or PITA will jump on it, give it a big name, and steal the ATA's thunder. There's nothing stopping the NSSA from changing the meaning of the second letter to "shotgun," or "shooting" and running their own Trap championship.
Nobody's getting insulted. You're just getting your feelings hurt because a lot of people want to change something you're happy with, and you don't have the ammo to fight them off.
By the way, "experience" in what, shooting, site selection, marketing, travel, shopping, dining?
Why not leave it where it is? It is, after all, at the best trapshooting facility in the world. Leave that for what? Something not as good? Why in the world would anyone want to do that?
OK some might want something not as good just because it is closer to them, but why should the rest of us put up with that? We are willing to go to the best place, just as we were willing to go to Vandalia when the Grand was there. If they are not willing to go to Sparta, that's their choice. They just can't go to the Grand, that's all.
Neil
Interesting observation:
Sparta was built by the State.
Las Vegas was built by the County (land courtesy of the BLM)
Could the Grand survive without public money? Maybe the folks at the Cardinal Center are on to something.
Are you under 40?
Say it isn't so there is something you don't have an answer for, a better suggestion for hard to believe with your track record.
BTW are you even old enough to drive????? Tell me how can someone your age become an expert in everything in such a short time. When your parents tell you something are you this thickheaded with them?
"Nobody's getting insulted. You're just getting your feelings hurt because a lot of people want to change something you're happy with, and you don't have the ammo to fight them off."
Fight them why would I do that I don't care what they change they give there opinions I give mine. They most of them have been around long enough to understand what is going on. Yo don't want to understand because to do that you have to read and understand. Your to busy writing to understand what other have written or why they have written it.
Do us all a favor crawl back under your rock and work with your solution machine for a while.
Bob Lawless
Bob, I've never seen your driver's license, so I have no idea how old you are. You can't attack me when I offer a conclusion AND when I ask a question. Doing so is just being bitter and nasty.
40 is really old. Lots of Trapshooters are older than that. All I'm saying is that the new people are going to have ideas that the previous people didn't.
No idea what this one is referring to.
"I've never seen your driver's license, so I have no idea how old you are."????
"You can't attack me when I offer a conclusion AND when I ask a question. Doing so is just being bitter and nasty."
Once again you are incorrect I can attack you any GD time I want to just what can you do about it. After all would that be any different than what you are doing?
"All I'm saying is that the new people are going to have ideas that the previous people didn't."
That is all you think you are saying. You tell everyone here how to think about what they already have formed opinions about. You make suggestions with no facts to back them up. You site states and cities where you say the Grand should be held like Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, or Nevada cities like Atlanta, or Vegas. No facts like are there clubs that have enough Traps to host the grand.
So you think that is all you are saying? Well it would appear to many of us that you think you know more about the cities and states you mention and their capabilities of hosting the Grand than the rest he do. That is what all of your post here reek of you, you ,you. Everything is about you you give your opinion with a ludicrous statement and when someone opposes what you have said you attack. It all about you.
As an example Barry said,
"S357 - your continued lack of knowledge about ATA shooting continues to astound us."
Your reply was,
"Barry, you're badly missing the point and saying some goofy things. This discussion is about weather and logistics."
What does that have to do with your lack of knowledge about ATA shooting???
This discussion is not about weather or logistics it is about the location of the Grand. Of course you have made it about what you wish to talk about. The person that started this thread titled it about Grand locations. So what right. You have to tell everyone that it is about weather and logistics....DUH!!!!
Instead of just BLOWING SMOKE up everyone, er ah Skirt why don't you try to understand that you don't have all the answers!!!!! I give up I am once again going to stop trying to get through a Granite Block.
Bob Lawless
Ivanhoe -
No, I cannot guarantee the 40 will be enough but 120 appears to be way too many right now. Time will tell. 40 traps would be enough if the purses were compulsory! That's right. You play, you pay. That's going to start a real sh*tstorm I think. Just a thought. I would hope that that many are needed in the near future but I don't see that happening with the division there appears to be amongst the troops. For now, I guess I'd like to see 40 traps in several locations while the organization gets their s*it together.
I for one was one of those people that was not very happy to see the Grand leave Ohio. I got over it even though it was very convenient for me to run down there for a day if that's all the time I had and shoot a couple hundred targets but on the flip side, I also realize that there were many that were not afforded the same convenience that do now with the move to Sparta. Sooo, why not allow the grand to move around the country allowing others the same convenience? I keep hearing about the shooter base being located right where I am in the Mid-West. How many P.I.T.A. shooters and West coast ATA shooters are there that would come if the Grand moved to Vegas every 3 years or so? Any California Delegates out there that can answer thst or me? Yeah, You would lose the East coast for the most part but you'll pick up the West so that may be a wash as far as numbers. The Class A motor home brigade would go to Vegas or Timbuktu for that matter so they don't figure into this equation. I would fly to Vegas in the Fall every few years for the Grand. My wife would even go. It would be something to look forward to every few years. It's the little guys that you would be catering to for once. They are what is going to decide whether you live or die as an organization.
There are a whole lot more little indians than Chiefs in the ATA. It's about time the cheifs figured that part out and started putting their ears to the ground a little more often to hear whats going on. Seems like that unless you shoot at least 7,500 targets a year, your opinion doesn't count for much. You can't vote for change because you're not a life member and the ATA is too slow to figure out how to offer a life membership payment plan that actually makes sense to the average worker bee. The NRA added "easy pay life" about 17 years ago or so. They still have it because so many people take advantage of it. ATA wants all their money in one year. Probably not going to happen as often than if you spread it out like NRA does. $25 a quarter until you're a life member. For the NRA, that's 10 years. Do the math people. The ATA would be getting $100 a year from me instead of $20 for the next 5 years.
Jeff
Jeff I am not say you are wrong I just have a problem knowing that this and other threads of it nature are suggested because those that are making the suggestion. Feel that it would help attendance at the Grand. They don't seem to realize that for what ever the reason that the shooters come up with they are the one that are making the decision to go or not to go. If changes continue to be made because some don't like this or that eventually no one will go to any shoot unless it meets their spec. then no one will go to any of them!!!!
"I would hope that that many are needed in the near future but I don't see that happening with the division there appears to be among the troops."
This is what worries me if they were to allow the locations to change and the troops that are seemingly divided were all to go and there were not enough fields to accommodate everyone(40)it would be a bigger disaster than everyone thinks it is now. I don't think that would help the situation very much either.
I don't see it as a reason to cut off our noes to spite our faces.
Bob Lawless
Vegas in October does have a nice ring to it.
J.F.
"This discussion is not about weather or logistics it is about the location of the Grand."
AWESOME!
UTTERLY AWESOME!
Bob, that is one of the best circular arguments I've ever seen. Thank you. This will be added to my file of colossal logical fallacies.
Further, the five lines above that quote are also a riotous non sequitur, worthy of their own note, but you so outdid yourself in the quoted sentence that the battle was already won.
Bob, buddy, it becomes increasingly evident that you just don't quite grasp what's being said. Seriously, dude. Your responses are just insults, not arguments. It's like you don't know how to make an effective counter-argument.
All that blather above does nothing, and I mean nothing, to disprove the appeal of Vegas or other places as new locations. See? Do you "get it?" You rage against me, while making no contribution on the discussion of the larger point, so the argument advances, and all you've offered is "Don't wanna." Just digging in your heels won't help you win this.
Big Heap,
Your post above ..
"Interesting observation:
Sparta was built by the State.
Las Vegas was built by the County (land courtesy of the BLM)
Could the Grand survive without public money? Maybe the folks at the Cardinal Center are on to something."
Cardinal Center was build by a non shooter.. what is the difference??? Mr. Fishburn put millions of his own money into a business.. just as the state and county have put money into a business..
I'm sorry.. I'm missing your point ?? !! ??
We need to change the shoot date for sure. It's so stinking hot today (Sparta)you absolutely can't enjoy shooting. Skeet championships were changed to later in the year for the same reason, but at least they changed it..This sucks bad. GaryL.
Amarillo today: 96 degrees, heat index 93, humidity 22%
July was Las Vegas' HOTTEST month EVER!
For everyone's info, the Vegas site now has 24 traps. More are in the master plan, but with public money, who knows how many will actually be built.
Danny
Somebody took a college logic class.
If I read correctly, I thought they currently had 24 combination trap and skeet fields and 101 additional Trap Fields in the works. I think if they were given an event like the Grand, the necessary number of fields would suddenly materialize. Vegas is funny like that. Things just sort of happen and happen fast.
Jeff
The EC and powers that be picked Sparta over and above anyplace else that surfaced at the time even though there were a lot of people (members) who voiced their opinion against it for what ever reason ... Neil Winston is living proof that no matter what anybody thinks or why they think it the Grand is in Sparta, Illinois and will probably remain there as it strangles the life out of the ATA itself ... The EC/BOD knows but does not acknowledge the fact that the clubs and members who shoot at them who host ATA registered shoots are the soul support of the Association and has probably been the majority of income of the ATA ... The WSRC might be the best overall facility but it is not in the best place, once again as long as it only impacts the members and not the Brass Hats they really do not care ... You can bet the EC, Neil Winston, former EC and members of the Good Ol' Boys Club all have accomidations be it on site or close by so they could care less about the membership, which are the people who in fact support the ATA while the EC sucks the life out of the Association ... The attendance in Sparta keeps dropping so no one has to do anything other than sit back and watch as the EC allows it to happen and they get their expenses paid to attend other shoots across the coutry so they can have a meeting and call it a business trip ... The ATA needs a good house cleaning before it can be righted and put back on track ... WPT ... (YAC) ...
The owners, administrators and moderators of the Trapshooters.com have no obligation to keep objectionable messages off this forum. It is impossible for us to review all messages. All messages express the views of the author, and neither the owners, administrators or moderators of Trapshooters.com Discussion Forum will be held responsible for the content of any message. The owners, administrators and moderators of the Trapshooters.com Discussion Forum reserve the right to remove, edit, move or close any thread for any reason at our sole discretion. However, the owners, administrators and moderators are not monitoring or editing the site and are under no obligation to police it for items that some persons may find objectionable. [ Back ] To Register for full access to reply and create threads Click Here!
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Stumpi24
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 08:48 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: hunter44
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 09:03 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: thebirdislost
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 09:06 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Neil Winston
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 09:15 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: BigM-Perazzi
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 09:19 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: FRedmon
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 09:37 PM ET
Website Address:
http://www.tarheeltrap.com
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: fssberson
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 09:50 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 09:58 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: The Rock
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 10:08 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Barry C. Roach
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 10:10 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: BigM-Perazzi
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 10:11 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: walnutmaker
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 10:30 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: frostyman
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 11:05 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Doug Brown
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 11:08 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Stumpi24
Email:
Date: Fri, Jul 30, 2010 - 11:41 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: ljutic73
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 12:45 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: walnutmaker
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 02:11 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Hauxfan
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 04:54 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: stokinpls
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 06:23 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Pat Ireland
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 07:56 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: GROCERY GUY
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 08:23 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: hunter44
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 08:30 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: shadow
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 09:03 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: bobdog
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 09:18 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: WPT
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 11:04 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: ALF-99
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 11:45 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Jerry Parr
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 12:08 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: dmarbell
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 12:11 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: b12
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 01:01 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: walnutmaker
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 01:54 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: BigM-Perazzi
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 02:32 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: MTA Tom
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 02:51 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: dhip
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 03:20 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: BigM-Perazzi
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 06:32 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Bernie K
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 08:12 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: dverna
Email:
Date: Sat, Jul 31, 2010 - 09:54 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: jpollo
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 01:36 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Stumpi24
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 10:19 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Mark T
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 12:44 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: BigM-Perazzi
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 01:21 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: WPT
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 01:57 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Big Heap
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 02:05 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: hunter44
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 02:11 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Big Heap
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 02:20 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 04:08 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Barry C. Roach
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 07:10 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 07:17 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Barry C. Roach
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 07:23 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: HDLLLIII
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 07:31 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: BigM-Perazzi
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 07:49 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 08:03 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: HDLLLIII
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 08:22 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: HDLLLIII
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 08:29 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 08:37 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: blackfoot
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 08:38 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: BigM-Perazzi
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 09:00 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: bigdogtx
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 09:00 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 10:04 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: BigM-Perazzi
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 10:32 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 11:13 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: 1brucem
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 11:22 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: SilverShooter
Email:
Date: Sun, Aug 01, 2010 - 11:55 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Barry C. Roach
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 01:14 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 01:26 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Barry C. Roach
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 01:55 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 02:24 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Barry C. Roach
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 02:31 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 09:26 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Barry C. Roach
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 10:30 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: 320090T
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 11:01 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 11:05 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: team henges
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 11:06 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: blackfoot
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 12:52 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: dmarbell
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 02:31 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Bucko43
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 03:00 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: blackfoot
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 03:55 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: targetmaster
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 03:58 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 04:07 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: targetmaster
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 04:38 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Bucko43
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 04:41 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: blackfoot
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 06:07 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Maxum Moe
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 06:55 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: grnberetcj
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 07:13 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: targetmaster
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 07:25 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Stumpi24
Email:
Date: Mon, Aug 02, 2010 - 09:31 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: dmarbell
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 05:40 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: blackfoot
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 09:07 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 09:40 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: GoldEx
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 09:49 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 10:22 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: ivanhoe
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 12:01 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Big Heap
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 12:04 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: dickgtax
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 12:14 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Pull & Mark
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 12:20 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 12:34 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: ivanhoe
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 01:08 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 01:33 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Neil Winston
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 01:41 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Big Heap
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 01:44 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: ivanhoe
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 01:46 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 02:46 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: ivanhoe
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 03:40 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: GoldEx
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 04:00 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: ivanhoe
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 04:41 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Jack Frost
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 04:47 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: smoking357
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 04:53 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: FlaLagarto
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 06:10 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: slugbug1
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 06:54 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: jbbor
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 07:46 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: jbbor
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 07:54 PM ET
Website Address:
http://www.lvrj.com/news/las-vegans-swelter-through-month-of-record-heat-99810549.html
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: dmarbell
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 10:54 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: Barry C. Roach
Email:
Date: Tue, Aug 03, 2010 - 11:18 PM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: GoldEx
Email:
Date: Wed, Aug 04, 2010 - 08:58 AM ET
Website Address:
Subject:
Why not have different location for Grand American
From: WPT
Email:
Date: Wed, Aug 04, 2010 - 09:52 AM ET
Website Address:
To Login to the discussion web Click Here!
To report problems with this site email email us